Who should be able to edit?

[MaestroX]

Who do you think should be able to edit the music encyclopedia? Should it be open to everyone to edit?

Due to the software move, the music encyclopedia's user base is not based of the forum user base so you can not login at the moment. So we have two choices here, both with their pros and cons. We can

• Have the encyclopedia use the same user accounts as the forum
• Have seperate accounts for the encyclopedia and forum

What you guys think?

[Sheba Queen]

I believe that not every forum participant will want to be involved in the Music Encyclopedia Project. While instead most editors and writers will most probably participate on the forums. I suggest to create separate accounts for Wikipedia, and if any editing must be done, it should be reported to the legitimate author, or an editor. It sounds unctuous that just anyone could register on the forums, access the project and edit freely someone else's articles. However I'm open to any opinion, I might be wrong.

In bona fide,
Sheba Queen

[MaestroX]

I agree, As you said, not every forum participant will want to be involved in the Music Encyclopedia Project, which is true. I think this will also not clutter up the encyclopedia's user list with none active editors